 |
![[spacer]](images/spacer.gif) |
3B Design and Systems #6
To reduce the chance of system failure, performance testing is often conducted using small-scale models, computer simulations, analogous systems, or just the parts of the system thought to be least reliable....
|
![[spacer]](images/spacer.gif) |
| | | |
 |
![[spacer]](images/spacer.gif) |
11A Systems #2
Understanding how things work and designing solutions to problems of almost any kind can be facilitated by systems analysis....
|
![[spacer]](images/spacer.gif) |
| |
|
|

![[spacer]](images/spacer_green.gif)
Send us feedback
Print this lesson
|
![[spacer]](images/spacer.gif) |
Science Is a Breeze: Using Wind Tunnels
![[spacer]](images/teal_spacer.gif)
Purpose
To build and analyze a wind tunnel system and conduct tests to compare the drag on various objects in a wind tunnel.
![[spacer]](images/teal_spacer.gif)
Context
This lesson will begin with an article online about wind tunnels. The article provides an appropriate vehicle for introducing and discussing the role of testing designs by describing the role of wind tunnels in the development of aircraft designs. It describes each of the five major parts of a wind tunnel and uses animation and interactive Java-based content to illustrate and demonstrate how a wind tunnel operates. The concepts of lift and drag are discussed. The needs for, and precursors to, wind tunnels are also briefly discussed. The article provides descriptions and links to other educational wind tunnel resources, and to information about NASA's operational wind tunnels. To help improve student understanding of why performance testing is often done using small-scale models, this lesson will have students test various objects in a wind tunnel. Students will first build a wind tunnel and then they will test polyhedrons in it and then toy cars. This lesson should build on design concepts students learned at the previous grade level; namely, that almost all control systems have inputs, outputs, and feedback and that design usually requires taking constraints into account. The lesson also reinforces what students at the 9-12 grade level should be doing. According to research, students at this level should be moving to higher levels of critical and creative thinking through progressively more demanding design and technology work. They need practice as individuals and as members of a group in developing and defining ideas using drawings and models. (Benchmarks for Science Literacy, p. 51.)
![[spacer]](images/teal_spacer.gif)
Planning Ahead
Materials:
Preparation: You should begin by reading the Wind Tunnel Teacher's Guide, on the Observatorium website. Then, review Laboratories of Flight: Wind Tunnels, also on the Observatorium website. Students will read A (very) Little History and Parts of a Wind Tunnel. The website also offers ideas for how wind tunnels are used in education.
You will also want to read the instructions for the wind tunnel found at The Measurement of All Things: Tools of the Aeronautics Trade. They are very clearly written, contain a list of materials needed, and include instructions for tests that will be performed with the wind tunnel. Gather all of the materials needed to construct the wind tunnel. Also, gather materials needed for the tests in the wind tunnel. You will want to test the shapes suggested at the above site (cone, cube, pyramid, and tetrahedron). Collect at least five different cars for each wind tunnel. The cars should be of different styles such as a sports car, an SUV, and a van; ones that would have obviously different aerodynamic designs. You may want to use the Science is a Breeze: Using Wind Tunnels student E-Sheet provided with this lesson. This online E-Sheet provides students with direct links to articles they should read, as well as the journal questions used in this lesson.
![[spacer]](images/teal_spacer.gif)
Motivation
In this lesson, students will explore wind tunnels and their importance in the development of flight, primarily through Laboratories of Flight: Wind Tunnels. Although this lesson touches upon aerodynamics, the main focus will be on technological issues.
Have students read the sections on A (very) Little History and Parts of a Wind Tunnel, found at the Observatorium's Laboratories of Flight: Wind Tunnels.
You may wish to discuss some of the new vocabulary words with the class before they read the article independently. A glossary is included in the teacher's guide to assist you.
Students can work in small groups to explore the resource, but have each student look for and write down answers to these questions in their science journals as they read: - Why was bird flight not the best model for human flight?
- What does the settling chamber do?
- What is the role of the contraction cone, test section, diffuser cone, and drive section?
- What is considered the "input" of this system? What is the "output"?
- Why is a closed loop system an improvement over an open loop system?
After you have discussed these questions, tell students that they will build a wind tunnel and use it to test various objects.
![[spacer]](images/teal_spacer.gif)
Development
Distribute the instructions for building a wind tunnel described in the The Measurement of All Things: Tools of the Aeronautics Trade print out. Assign students to groups of three or four (depending on class size). Four groups are required to build a wind tunnel. If you have more than four groups, build two wind tunnels. Assign each group one of the "engineering tasks" as described in the instructions. After each group is finished with its portion of the wind tunnel, have the groups combine each part. Next, conduct a discussion of the basic concepts of aerodynamics. To do this, show the class pictures of two different cars or trucks (one that is very aerodynamic, like a sports car, and one that is not, like an old VW van). Have them compare the shape of the two vehicles and ask them which one will have a greater drag and why. (Drag is affected by the velocity of the wind, and the cross sectional area of the object. The less cross sectional area being hit by the wind, the lower the drag will be. The wedge shape of a sports car will have a much smaller area than the flat front of the VW van.) Now have students complete the experiments and questions from the activity on the website. After students have completed the wind tunnels activity, they should test the toy cars in the tunnel for comparison. Have students use the Science is a Breeze: Using Wind Tunnels student sheet for instructions on how to test the toy cars and to help them organize the data that they collect.
![[spacer]](images/teal_spacer.gif)
Assessment
To assess student understanding of how a wind-tunnel system works, have each student answer these questions about the wind tunnels they built in their science journals: - When a wind tunnel is working, what does it do? (It creates a high speed flow of air for testing the aerodynamics of various objects.)
- For the wind tunnel to work, must it receive any input? (It must receive air and electricity to run the fan.)
- What, if any, output does your wind tunnel produce? (It produces fast moving air.)
- Identify at least four parts of the wind tunnel. Describe what each part does, and tell how each part contributes to the system as a whole. (The settling chamber, contraction cone, test section, diffuser cone, and drive section are all parts of the wind tunnel.)
- Which of the parts that you have identified is the most reliable? Which is the least reliable?
- Could any of the parts of the wind tunnel you made be constructed of different material without affecting how the system works? Explain your answer. (Answers may vary.)
- If your wind tunnel stops working, how would you go about fixing it? (Answers may vary.)
- Could someone develop a computer simulation of your wind tunnel? Explain your answer. (Answers may vary.)
![[spacer]](images/teal_spacer.gif)
Extensions
Rocket Launch is another Science NetLinks lesson that targets the same Design and Systems benchmark.
By discussing the Open Loop vs. Closed Loop page on the Observatorium website with the class, you can help students understand some of the elements of systems design. To help reinforce this idea, have students discuss how they can adapt the open wind tunnel they have built in this activity to make it a closed loop. What would be some of the advantages and disadvantages of doing this?
Wind Tunnels of NASA is an online version of a book which details the history of the development of flight and the use of wind tunnels for testing designs of airplanes, ships, and rockets.
The Supersonic Transport Wind Tunnel Test allows students to follow a supersonic transport wind tunnel test through the eyes of the program manager. The site records the wind tunnel test as team members assemble their model, check out all of the instruments on it, install it in the tunnel, and then test it.
Other Wind Tunnel designs are available online from Laboratories of Flight: Wind Tunnels.
Created :10/20/2001
|